This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

The road to Bitcoin

Lesson 2 of 6
By the end of this lesson you’ll be able to explain the double-spend problem in one sentence, name the four ideas that led to Bitcoin, and say what happened on 3 January 2009.
A collage of two identical men in long dark overcoats standing far apart on a cobbled square. One blue bowler hat sits on both their heads at once, its brim stretched across the gap between them.

Why digital cash needed a bank

Anything digital can be copied. A file that stands for a dollar can be sent to two people at once, and both copies look real.

Bitcoin’s own vocabulary page describes the result: “If a malicious user tries to spend their bitcoins to two different recipients at the same time, this is double spending.”

From David Chaum’s 1982 paper on digital cash to 2008, the only fix was a trusted record keeper. Someone had to hold the one true list of who owned what, and that someone was a bank or a company.

The Bitcoin white paper describes where that left online commerce: it had come to “rely almost exclusively on financial institutions serving as trusted third parties.” That’s the five-party card payment from lesson 1, carried over to the internet.

A record keeper can also refuse you, reverse a payment, go bust or be shut down. Several people spent the next two decades trying to do without one.

Four ideas before 2009

Four earlier ideas led to Bitcoin, and it uses parts of the last three. The white paper cites two of them by name, Hashcash and b-money.

Blind signatures
Who and when
David Chaum, 1982
What it added
Payments a bank could sign without seeing who spent them
Hashcash
Who and when
Adam Back, 1997
What it added
Proof of work: a token that costs computing to make and is cheap to check
b-money
Who and when
Wei Dai, 1998
What it added
Money created by broadcasting the solution to a computational problem
Bit gold
Who and when
Nick Szabo, 2005
What it added
A chain of proofs of work, each built on the last

Continue with The Crossover Pro

The rest of this story, plus two paid editions a week. $24.99 a month, or $249 a year. Already a member? Sign in above.

Subscribe to Pro